What Happens If a Parent Loses Capacity Without a Power of Attorney
Usually, a court case. Without a durable power of attorney, a family generally has to petition the Orphans' Court to have the parent found incapacitated and a guardian appointed under Chapter 55 of Title 20, and 20 Pa.C.S. § 5511 requires a hearing and clear and convincing evidence of incapacity before the court can act.
That process changed in 2024. Act 61 of 2023, signed December 14, 2023, and effective June 11, 2024, requires the court to appoint a lawyer for the parent if the parent has not hired one, and that lawyer must advocate for the parent's expressed wishes. The petition must also allege specific facts showing that less restrictive alternatives were considered or tried and why they are unavailable or insufficient, and anyone serving as guardian for three or more people must be certified. In other words, a family petition now meets a lawyer on the parent's side, and the family has to explain why something short of guardianship will not work. This guide covers why guardianship happens, how a Pennsylvania case works, who can serve, what guardians must report, and how a power of attorney avoids it. It describes how the law generally works and is not legal advice.
Why Does a Missing Power of Attorney Lead to Court?
Guardianship is a court order that gives a chosen person authority to make certain decisions for an adult the court has found incapacitated. A power of attorney does something similar without a court: the parent names an agent in advance.
When no one holds that authority, banks, care facilities and government agencies have no one they can legally deal with on the parent's behalf. Our firm's power of attorney page puts it plainly: if a person becomes incapacitated without a power of attorney, the family will be forced to seek a court-appointed guardian, which involves a hearing before the probate court.
How Does a Guardianship Case Work in Pennsylvania?
The main steps under § 5511 look like this:
A petition is filed in the Orphans' Court division of the county where the parent lives.
The parent receives written notice in large type and simple language explaining the purpose and seriousness of the proceeding and the rights that can be lost.
The court appoints counsel for the parent if the parent has not retained a lawyer, whether or not the parent can pay.
At the hearing, the petitioner must prove incapacity by clear and convincing evidence.
The court decides whether a guardian is needed and for which decisions.
Section 5511 also says the appointed lawyer must keep a normal client-attorney relationship with the parent under the rules of professional conduct and advocate for the parent's expressed wishes. If the parent disagrees with the petition, the family should expect the parent's lawyer to say so.
A guardian may be appointed over the person, the estate or both. The Pennsylvania courts' Office of Elder Justice in the Courts describes a guardian's role as making the financial, medical and personal decisions the court has found the person unable to make. Our post comparing durable and limited powers of attorney explains the lighter-touch alternatives a petition now has to address.
Who Can Be Appointed Guardian?
Not always a family member. Section 5511(f) lets the court appoint any qualified individual, a corporate fiduciary, a nonprofit corporation, a guardianship support agency or a county agency. It bars appointing a paid residential care provider or anyone whose interests conflict with the incapacitated person's, unless it is clearly shown that no alternative exists.
The statute tells the court to give preference, if appropriate, to a nominee of the incapacitated person. Since Act 61, a person seeking appointment as guardian of three or more incapacitated people must be certified, with a background check and an exam given by a national nonprofit guardianship certification organization. Our firm's power of attorney page notes that the court is not obligated to use a family member and in many cases uses a professional.
What Does a Guardian Have to Report?
Guardianship comes with ongoing court oversight. The Office of Elder Justice in the Courts explains that every court-appointed guardian must file an Annual Report of the Person and/or an Annual Report of the Estate each year, and that guardians of the estate must file an inventory within 90 days of appointment. The courts' site also points guardians to the statewide Guardianship Tracking System and its training workshops.
For a family member who takes on the role, that means recordkeeping for as long as the guardianship lasts.
How Does a Power of Attorney Prevent Guardianship?
A durable power of attorney keeps working after the person who signed it loses capacity, which is exactly when it is needed. Our post on understanding power of attorney documents covers the different types.
The law also gives a power of attorney weight if a guardianship case happens anyway. Under 20 Pa.C.S. § 5604(c), a person can nominate the guardian of their estate or person in a durable power of attorney, and the court must follow that nomination except for good cause or disqualification. If a guardian is appointed, the agent becomes accountable to the guardian as well as to the principal, and the court decides whether and how far the power of attorney stays in effect.
Health decisions need their own documents. A health care power of attorney and a living will name who decides and record what you want. Our guides to health care directives and how a living will differs from a regular will explain both.
What Should Families Do Now?
It depends on where your parent is today.
If your parent can still understand and sign documents, schedule a meeting to prepare a durable power of attorney, a health care power of attorney and a living will now.
If your parent's capacity is in question, talk with an attorney and your parent's doctor before anyone signs anything. A power of attorney has to be signed by the parent, not by the family.
If guardianship is already likely, gather financial statements, medical records and a list of monthly bills so the petition can be supported and the guardian can act quickly.
FAQ
Does my parent get a lawyer in a guardianship case?
Yes. Since Act 61 took effect on June 11, 2024, the court must appoint counsel for the alleged incapacitated person if one has not been retained, and that lawyer advocates for the parent's expressed wishes.
What does the court have to find?
Incapacity, proved by clear and convincing evidence at a hearing, under 20 Pa.C.S. § 5511.
Will the court appoint me as my parent's guardian?
Possibly, but not automatically. The court may appoint any qualified individual or agency and gives preference, if appropriate, to the parent's own nominee.
Can a power of attorney name a future guardian?
Yes. Section 5604(c) lets a person nominate a guardian in a durable power of attorney, and the court follows that nomination except for good cause or disqualification.
Does a guardian have to file reports?
Yes. Guardians file annual reports, and guardians of the estate file an inventory within 90 days of appointment.
Can I sign a power of attorney for my parent?
No. Your parent has to sign it. If your parent can no longer understand and sign one, guardianship may be the remaining option.
Powers of Attorney and Elder Planning in Greensburg
David K. Lucas & Associates PLLC, at 140 South Main Street, Suite 301, in Greensburg, prepares durable powers of attorney, health care directives, living wills and wills so families are less likely to need a guardianship case. Attorney David K. Lucas has been a member of the Pennsylvania Bar Association's Elder Law Division since 2000, and the firm offers free consultations on powers of attorney and in most cases can quote upfront fees. Learn more about our health care directive planning.
Visit David K. Lucas & Associates or call 724-836-3300 today. Contact us for more information.
Comments