What Is a Right of First Refusal in a Custody Order?

A right of first refusal is a custody order provision that requires a parent who cannot care for the child during his or her own custodial time to offer that time to the other parent before calling a babysitter, relative or daycare. Pennsylvania does not require one. It is a term parents agree to, or a judge includes, when it serves the child's best interest under the custody factors in 23 Pa.C.S. § 5328.
Pennsylvania's Superior Court has upheld judges who said no. In Humphrey v. Ross, a non-precedential decision from York County issued August 24, 2023, the Superior Court found no abuse of discretion when a trial court declined to give a mother custodial time while the father was at work. In that opinion, the court described its earlier decision in R.P. v. K.F. (2020), which upheld a refusal to give a mother a right of first refusal over the paternal grandmother, reasoning that it served the child's best interest to let the father use third parties, in his discretion, during his own custodial time. The takeaway is that a right of first refusal is not automatic, and the case for one has to be about the child rather than fairness between parents. This guide explains how the clause works, how judges decide, when it helps, and what a good one says. It describes how custody law generally works and is not legal advice.

How Does a Right of First Refusal Work?
The clause turns on a trigger set in the order itself. A provision might say that if a parent will be unavailable for more than a stated number of hours, or overnight, during his or her custodial time, that parent must first offer the time to the other parent.
Everything else depends on the wording. The order may say how the offer is made, how quickly the other parent must answer, who handles transportation, and whether certain relatives are exempt. If the other parent declines or does not answer in time, the parent with custody arranges other care.
Because the clause lives inside a custody order, it sits alongside the rest of the schedule. Our post on the difference between legal and physical custody in Pennsylvania explains how physical custody time is divided in the first place.
Does Pennsylvania Law Require a Right of First Refusal?
No. The Superior Court in Humphrey v. Ross treated the question as one for the trial court's discretion, and it upheld the trial court's decision not to build Mother's time around Father's work schedule. Its description of R.P. v. K.F. makes the same point from a different angle: letting a parent choose a grandparent or other caregiver during his own time can serve the child's best interest.
That does not mean judges never include the clause, and parents can put one in an agreed custody order simply because they both want it. It means a parent asking a judge to impose one should be ready to explain why it helps the child.
How Do Pennsylvania Judges Decide Whether to Include One?
Through the same best-interest analysis that governs every custody decision. Since Kayden's Law, Act 8 of 2024, took effect 120 days after its April 15, 2024 enactment, § 5328(a) directs courts to give substantial weighted consideration to the factors that affect the child's safety.
Several of the factors listed on our firm's child custody page bear directly on a right of first refusal:
The level of cooperation and conflict between the parties, including which parent is more likely to encourage frequent and continuing contact with the other parent
The proximity of the parties' residences
Each party's employment schedule and availability to care for the child, or ability to make appropriate child-care arrangements
The need for stability and continuity in the child's education, family life and community life
A clause that looks sensible for two parents who live ten minutes apart and communicate well can look very different for parents who live an hour apart or who cannot exchange a text without an argument.
When Does a Right of First Refusal Help, and When Does It Backfire?
It tends to help when parents live close together, have flexible schedules and can communicate quickly. The child gets more time with a parent instead of a sitter, and each parent has a clear rule to follow.
It can backfire in other situations:
High-conflict cases, where every short absence becomes a dispute about whether the trigger was met
Cases involving safety concerns or a Protection from Abuse order, where a clause that requires contact may conflict with the child's safety or with the order itself
Schedules with frequent short absences, where constant handoffs disrupt the child's routine
Families where a grandparent or other relative already provides stable care, as in R.P. v. K.F.
An attorney can help you decide whether to ask for the clause, agree to it, or oppose it.
What Should a Right of First Refusal Clause Include?
Vague clauses produce disputes. A workable provision usually answers these questions:
How long an absence triggers the clause, stated in hours or as overnight
Whether work shifts, errands and social events all count
How the offer must be made, such as by text or a co-parenting app, and how quickly the other parent must respond
Who provides transportation if the other parent accepts
Whether named relatives, such as a grandparent, are exempt
What happens if the other parent declines or does not respond
Our post on how to establish a child custody agreement in Pennsylvania covers how these terms become part of an order. If grandparents are part of the child care picture, our post on grandparents' rights in custody cases explains their separate legal standing.
What If the Other Parent Ignores the Clause?
A right of first refusal in a court order is part of that order. If a parent repeatedly ignores it, the other parent can raise it with the court. Our post on what happens if a parent violates a custody order walks through enforcement options. Keep a simple record of dates, times and messages so the court can see the pattern rather than a single missed call.
FAQ
Is a right of first refusal required in Pennsylvania custody orders?
No. The Superior Court has treated it as a matter for the trial court's discretion under the best-interest factors in 23 Pa.C.S. § 5328.
How many hours trigger a right of first refusal?
Whatever the order says. Parents and judges set the trigger, such as a number of hours or an overnight absence.
Does it apply while a parent is at work?
Only if the order says so. In Humphrey v. Ross, the Superior Court upheld a decision not to give the mother custodial time while the father worked.
Can a grandparent watch the child instead of the other parent?
If the order allows it. In R.P. v. K.F., as described in Humphrey v. Ross, the Superior Court upheld a father's discretion to use the paternal grandmother during his time.
Can I add a right of first refusal to an existing order?
Yes, by agreement of both parents or by asking the court to modify the order. The court will apply the best-interest factors.
Is a right of first refusal a good idea if there is a PFA?
It may not be. Safety factors get substantial weighted consideration under § 5328, and a clause requiring contact can create problems. Talk with an attorney first.
Child Custody Representation in Greensburg
David K. Lucas & Associates PLLC, at 140 South Main Street, Suite 301, in Greensburg, represents parents in custody cases throughout Westmoreland County and the surrounding counties. Attorney Brittney E. Reay is the lead attorney on the firm's domestic relations matters, including custody, and is a member of the Westmoreland County Bar Association's Family Law Committee. Whether you want a right of first refusal in your order or want to keep one out, we can help you draft terms that fit your family.
Visit David K. Lucas & Associates or call 724-836-3300 today. Contact us for more information.




Comments